Blog

FCC Vote vs. Local Control

At issue is who gets to control the location of antennas for 5G.  

Verizon and AT&T won big at the Federal Communications Commission on Wednesday as the agency voted to make it easier and cheaper to place 800,000 small antennas for super-fast 5G services on utility poles, traffic lights, sidewalks, and other public areas.

Philadelphia; Santa Barbara, Calif., and other municipalities have blasted the new rules as subsidies to profitable wireless companies through low fees and mandated quick response times for 5G antenna applications that will flood local government offices. A top Philadelphia official said Wednesday that the financial impact from the FCC’s action “could be substantial.”

The boxy 5G equipment sprouts five-foot antennas on poles or buildings. They will proliferate like weeds throughout the nation over the next decade.

“The rhetoric is that towns want to hold up this new network,” John Davis, the manager at Doylestown Borough in Bucks County, which spent about $150,000 fighting 5G antennas proposed there, said Wednesday. “And that’s not so at all.”

Pennsylvania and other state governments also have passed, or are considering, wireless-friendly legislation to help the companies upgrade their networks with the use of public rights-of-way.

Introduced this summer, proposed Pennsylvania legislation would strip local towns of much of their zoning authority over small-cell antenna placements in public rights-of-way. The measure would be another blow to local towns that would like to retain control over the antennas when they are proposed for historic districts, in neighborhoods without utility poles, or in front of residential homes.

The new FCC rules do not diminish local zoning authority over placement of the antennas but instead set deadlines for towns to process applications and fees. FCC officials warned that local red tape and exorbitant fees would slow 5G for years and cost billions of dollars as town officials look at the antennas as revenue sources.

FCC Commissioner Brendan Carr, the prime backer of the new federal rules, said Wednesday that the favorable treatment for wireless companies was “about economic leadership for the next decade. Those are the stakes.”

Carr compared the potential of 5G to the innovation related to the current 4G wireless network that unleashed the “app economy” and services such as Uber and Lyft in recent years. He also warned that the U.S. was losing out to China in developing a 5G network and that the nation had to close the gap.

Wireless firms and their infrastructure providers, such as Crown Castle, are expected to install the antennas over the next decade in the next wave of wireless-technology upgrades, leading to driverless cars, internet-of-things devices that will automate daily life, and high-speed wireless broadband services to compete with Comcast Corp. and other cable companies.

“At the FCC, we’re working hard to ensure that the

United States leads the world in developing this next generation of wireless connectivity so that American consumers and our nation’s economy enjoy the immense benefits that 5G will bring,” FCC Chairman Ajit Pai said in a statement.

FCC rules force a shot clock on towns, making them respond to wireless companies requests for 5G antennas within 60 days. They also have a deadline of 90 days for new utility poles with 5G antennas. The rules set $270 annual fees for each antenna or pole and a $500 application fee per antenna, though this can be slashed if a wireless company seeks antennas in batches, or multiple ones at the same time, according to the FCC website on Wednesday.

Verizon was pleased. “Today’s action by the Federal Communications Commission to accelerate small-cell deployment is another critical step toward making our nation’s 5G future a reality, sooner than later,” said Nicola Palmer, Verizon’s head of wireless networks.

The “order will significantly boost 5G deployment by adopting common-sense guidelines, modeled on state legislation, that reduce the time and cost of small-cell deployments while accounting for legitimate local interests,” Palmer added. “We would like to thank the FCC for demonstrating vision and determination … as we enter the 5G age.”

Philadelphia wasn’t so ebullient.

“Today’s actions by the FCC ignore longstanding local authority to manage the public rights-of-way. The city has agreements in place for service providers to pay up to $3,000 per year per site with a 3 percent annual escalator, consistent with city ordinance. To incentivize development, the fee starts at $3,000 but falls to $250 to reflect economies of scale,” Michael Carroll, the city’s deputy managing director for transportation, said Wednesday after the FCC vote.

“Today, the FCC declared that service providers should be charged a flat annual fee of $270 per site, leaving the city’s existing agreements and ordinance subject to judicial challenge,” Carroll added. “The financial impact to the city could be substantial.”

Santa Barbara Mayor Cathy Murillo said in aletter filed with the FCC that the rules “effectively give access to public property to for-profit companies to install their equipment and to sell their private services, while limiting the ability of jurisdictions to recover their costs through the collection of rents and fees for the use of their public right-of-way.”

The new FCC rules make it impossible for towns to do what Doylestown Borough officials have done over the last year: force Crown Castle to pay the borough what they consider appropriate fees for the use of the public rights-of-way.

When Doylestown finally settled with Crown Castle in July, the borough won the right to reduce the number of poles as well as camouflage and relocate some of them. It also won a 5 percent share of the revenues for the services Verizon or other companies sell through some of those Crown Castle small cells and $750 a year for other antennas.

The Doylestown deal with Crown Castle — which will lease the small-cell antennas to Verizon and other wireless carriers — should be grandfathered, thus not jeopardized by the new FCC rules, Davis said. But other towns will miss out on a similar lucrative deal.

Recommended Posts

More Than Membership: How PAB Helps Pennsylvania Broadcasters Strengthen Their Stations and Stay Ahead

More Than Membership: How PAB Helps Pennsylvania Broadcasters Strengthen Their Stations and Stay Ahead In the dynamic world of broadcasting, staying ahead of the curve is essential for success. Pennsylvania broadcasters have a powerful ally in the PA Association of Broadcasters (PAB)—a membership-driven trade association that offers a wealth of resources, advocacy, and community support. As the first state broadcast association in the nation, PAB is dedicated to ensuring that Pennsylvania radio and TV stations of all sizes are well-equipped to navigate the ever-changing media landscape. Advocacy and Legal & Compliance Support Navigating the complex regulatory environment is a challenge for any broadcaster. PAB provides invaluable legal support to its members, ensuring compliance with both state and federal broadcasting regulations. Through partnerships with seasoned legal counsel from Wilkinson Barker Knauer for federal issues and Ballard Spahr, LLP for state matters, PAB members have access to expert guidance that helps them avoid costly compliance pitfalls. Moreover, PAB's Alternative Broadcast Inspection Program (ABIP) offers FCC-style inspections that save time and money by proactively identifying and addressing compliance issues. PAB also supports the Emergency Alert System (EAS), ensuring that members are prepared to distribute public safety warnings in line with FCC mandates. Cultivating Workforce and Talent Attracting and retaining top talent is a priority for Pennsylvania broadcasters, and PAB plays a crucial role in workforce development. The Broadcast Engineer Futures Enterprise program reimburses member stations for Society of Broadcast Engineers (SBE) memberships and training, nurturing homegrown engineering talent. Additionally, PAB's Internship Reimbursement Program provides stations the opportunity to offer valuable hands-on experience to interns across various roles, from sales to IT and engineering. Training and Revenue Growth Opportunities Professional development is at the heart of PAB's mission to empower broadcasters. Through partnerships with P1 Learning, the Radio Advertising Bureau (RAB), and other industry leaders, PAB offers a range of expert-led training programs. Members can access free RAB courses, expanded RAB Live training webinars, and the Ten Minute Trainer Network, all designed to enhance skills and drive station revenue. PAB also provides Broadcast Innovation Grants, offering financial support for participation in prestigious industry events and courses, further enhancing members' expertise and competitive edge. Fostering Community Recognition and Engagement PAB recognizes the importance of community engagement in broadcasting success. The organization hosts the annual Excellence in Broadcasting Awards, celebrating the achievements of Pennsylvania stations and individuals. This event not only honors outstanding contributions but also strengthens the sense of community among broadcasters across the state. PAB's Broadcast NOW! program pairs school communications teams with local stations, fostering early career interest in broadcasting and building a pipeline of future talent. Additionally, The Frequency monthly newsletter and PAB's blog offer valuable insights on topics such as FCC compliance, AI in broadcasting, and strategies for increasing local radio ad revenue. Conclusion The PA Association of Broadcasters offers much more than membership; it provides a comprehensive suite of resources, advocacy, and community support that empowers Pennsylvania broadcasters to thrive. From legal compliance to professional development, PAB is committed to helping its members navigate today's challenges and prepare for what's next. To learn more about the benefits of PAB membership and how it can strengthen your station, contact the PA Association of Broadcasters today. Join PAB and become part of a vibrant community dedicated to advancing broadcasting across Pennsylvania.

How Nonprofits Can Amplify Their Community Impact Through Radio and TV Public Education Campaigns

Amplifying Community Impact: How Nonprofits Can Leverage Radio and TV Public Education Campaigns In today's digital age, where social media platforms and online advertising dominate, one might question the relevance of traditional media like radio and TV. Yet, for nonprofits aiming to amplify their community impact, these platforms remain powerful allies. Particularly in Pennsylvania, where the PA Association of Broadcasters (PAB) offers crucial support, radio and TV continue to play pivotal roles in public education campaigns. Why Traditional Broadcast Still Matters Radio and TV reach vast audiences across Pennsylvania, cutting through the digital clutter to deliver messages directly into homes. Unlike digital ads that users can easily skip or block, broadcast media captures attention, making it an effective tool for spreading awareness. For Pennsylvania nonprofits, this means tapping into a medium that can reach diverse demographics across urban and rural areas. Planning an Effective Campaign Understanding Your Goals and Audience Before launching a campaign, it's essential to define clear objectives. Are you raising awareness, driving donations, or promoting an event? Once your goals are set, identify your target audience. Understanding who you are speaking to will guide the tone, language, and content of your message. Crafting a Compelling Message A successful public education campaign hinges on a compelling message. Focus on clarity and emotion, ensuring your message resonates with your audience's values and needs. Whether it's a call to action or an informative piece, simplicity and relatability are key. Utilizing PSAs and Partnerships The Role of PSAs Public Service Announcements (PSAs) are a cost-effective way for nonprofits to broadcast their message. Many Pennsylvania radio and TV stations offer free airtime for PSAs, providing nonprofits with valuable exposure. However, securing these spots requires strategic planning and relationship-building with broadcasters. Building Relationships with Local Stations Engaging with local stations can significantly enhance your campaign's success. The PAB, based in Harrisburg, serves as a valuable resource for nonprofits looking to connect with stations across the state. By fostering these relationships, nonprofits can secure not only airtime but also potential collaborations for community affairs programs and interview segments. Measuring Impact and Success Tracking Your Campaign's Reach Measuring the impact of your campaign is crucial for understanding its effectiveness. Many broadcasters provide quarterly airtime reports, detailing when and where your message aired. These reports offer insights into the campaign's reach and can guide future strategies. Learning from Common Mistakes Avoid common pitfalls by ensuring your message is concise and tailored to your audience. Overly complex messages or unclear calls to action can dilute your campaign's impact. Additionally, regularly reviewing and adjusting your strategy based on feedback and performance data is vital for continuous improvement. Want to Learn More? Radio and TV remain invaluable tools for Pennsylvania nonprofits seeking to amplify their community impact through public education campaigns. By leveraging the resources and support of the PA Association of Broadcasters, nonprofits can effectively reach their target audiences with compelling messages that drive change. For nonprofits ready to explore the potential of broadcast media, connect with the PA Association of Broadcasters to start planning your next impactful campaign.

How to Attract and Retain Broadcast Talent in Pennsylvania

The broadcast industry in Pennsylvania, much like the broader media landscape across the United States, faces a unique set of challenges when it comes to attracting and retaining talent. As the media landscape evolves, fueled by technological advancements and changing audience preferences, the demand for skilled broadcast professionals has surged. Yet, many Pennsylvania stations find themselves competing fiercely for talent. Here, we explore actionable strategies to attract and retain broadcast talent in Pennsylvania, leveraging local insights and initiatives supported by the Pennsylvania Association of Broadcasters (PAB). Understanding the Talent Landscape Current Challenges The broadcast industry is grappling with a notable shortage of qualified professionals, particularly among multimedia journalists (MMJs). Historically, the industry has offered low pay compared to other sectors, making it difficult to attract and retain top talent. In fact, 69% of US employers report difficulties in finding skilled talent, highlighting the industry's challenge. Additionally, the rise of digital platforms has created alternative career pathways, further shrinking the pool of potential candidates. The challenge for Pennsylvania's broadcasters is to not only attract talent but retain it in the face of competition from other industries and sectors. Strategies for Attraction and Retention 1. Competitive Compensation and Benefits To attract top talent, Pennsylvania broadcasters must offer competitive compensation. This means not underpaying MMJs but treating all roles as integral parts of the team with clear career pathways. Compensation packages that include health benefits, flexible working arrangements, and bonuses can make broadcast roles more attractive. 2. Professional Development and Training The PAB provides a rich array of professional development initiatives, such as partnerships with the Radio Advertising Bureau (RAB) for training and certifications. Broadcasters should leverage these resources to enhance the skills of their staff, which not only improves job satisfaction but also retention. For new entrants, programs like the Confer Radio Talent Institute at Commonwealth University in Bloomsburg offer a solid foundation. With 70% of graduates landing their first broadcasting jobs post-completion, this institute serves as a vital talent pipeline for Pennsylvania's broadcasters. 3. Enhance Internship Programs Internships present a crucial pathway for nurturing new talent. The PAB's Broadcast Internship Reimbursement Program allows Pennsylvania broadcasters to offer competitive internships. Interns gain holistic exposure to areas like sales, community relations, and IT/engineering, preparing them for a comprehensive broadcasting career. 4. Recognizing and Rewarding Excellence Programs such as the PAB Excellence in Broadcasting Awards, which celebrate outstanding achievements in the field, help retain talent by recognizing their contributions. Encouraging a culture of recognition can foster a sense of belonging and encourage long-term commitment to the organization. 5. Foster Community Connections Local content still matters immensely. Pennsylvania broadcasters can strengthen their ties with communities through engagement in local events and initiatives. Community-connected journalism not only helps stations stay relevant but also provides journalists with meaningful work that can boost job satisfaction. Leveraging Technology and Innovation Amid these strategies, integrating technology can be a significant draw for talent. By adopting AI tools for tasks like transcription and content recommendations, broadcasters can increase efficiency, freeing journalists to focus on creative storytelling. This balance between technology and creativity can be appealing to prospective employees who value innovation. Conclusion In Pennsylvania, attracting and retaining broadcast talent requires a multifaceted approach that balances competitive compensation, professional development, community involvement, and technological innovation. By harnessing the resources and programs provided by the Pennsylvania Association of Broadcasters and others, stations can position themselves as attractive employers in a competitive landscape. For stations looking to implement these strategies or learn more about enhancing their talent management approach, the PA Association of Broadcasters is a valuable partner. Learn more by contacting PAB today.